5
22 Comments

Roast this idea

It is not well thought out but basically a simple plattform to trade backlinks. People could list their website and topics and stats, and maybe sell or connect with each other to trade out backlinks.

on April 18, 2023
  1. 5

    I would be wary of trading backlinks. If Google sees or suspects this, then websites can be penalized in rankings.

    See: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/link-building-guide/reciprocal-links/

    1. 1

      Thats an interesting blogpost, but as I understand if it is matching appropriatly it wont harm?

      1. 1

        If done appropriately, then yes it probably won't hurt and might help. As with many things in SEO, it's a little subjective and up to Google at the end of the day.

  2. 2

    Hello Moel.

    There are some platforms like this out there, although if by trading you mean an exchange of backlinks, ie. link exchanges, then I don't know of any like that, and Google has said things about that in the past. So, if your proposition is you link to me, I link to you, then there needs to be some relevance one way or both ways. Even then, link exchanges only work in certain situations, Partner pages, same local geographic location, servicing of the same audience due to some vertical symbiosis. Beyond that it's fishy, too risky, I'd stay away from it.

    When it comes to platforms already out there that are not link exchanges, then there is Bazoom, iCopyify, Link Builders, few others, typically you would be looking at either link insertion in an existing article, or the production of a new article with the required backlink.

    As for Google penalizing due to questionable backlinks; Google will make a big song and dance infrequently with much fanfare, like it has done over the years, and then you'll check out the backlink profile of competitors, and wonder when the next infrequent dance will be. But even the frequent Google updates can be quite damaging. It's obviously no way to setup foundations for a business that has a long-term goal.

    Typically Google will just ignore dodgy backlinks, as it can't prove you did it, and not your competitor. Unless the scope and scale of the operation is relatively large, and unfocused in the backlink building.

    However, what Google says, and what it actually does, doesn't always match, which is annoying for the people who do adhere to the guidelines as if it is gospel.

    As long as the links make sense in some way, between content, between brands, then there shouldn't be a problem. But it should be one way backlinking, not 2-way, not link exchanging.

    Cheers, Ace.

    1. 1

      Thanks a lot for this in depth reply!

  3. 2

    Good blogger know the power of good backlinks, they definetly dont buy!

  4. 2

    Trading backlinks publicly? Any thoughts on the risk of getting penalized by Google?

    1. 1

      I believe google penalizes only those who don’t match appropriately, or am I wrong?

  5. 2

    Just to second stevenkkim, based on my experience stakeholders who have a brand blog for SEO are very afraid of being penalized by Google, as that would make their entire business go down. That being said you're target market might not be such companies.

    1. 1

      I understand, but as long as they the connection is not too far fetched, i believe it will be alright or?

    1. 1

      that looks really interesting is this a marketplace?

        1. 2

          @BahauddinAziz thank you so much for tagging Smartlinks :)

          Just to add more context, typically in a marketplace we are selling or buying products but there won't be any selling going on in Smartlinks. Its a free barter community that works by automating a lot of manual work - No need to filter domains as per your criteria, or finding contact info, no tedious outreach process.

          Hopeful that the beta would be out in 2 weeks.

  6. 2

    This is a good idea - lmk if you get a waitlist going so I can sign up :)

    1. 1

      May be you would be interested in www.smartlinks.ai

    2. 1

      yay first letter of intent I guess!

  7. 1

    Good bloggers understand the significance of natural backlinks and never resort to buying them.

  8. 1

    How do people trade backlinks right now?

    1. 1

      one comment has pointed out really well where and how to trade

      1. 2

        Cool. I would go research that a ton. Talk to people who are trading. Then see if you idea still works.

  9. 0

    At Mass Cloth Supply, our crude materials are obtained from the main factories of the world to present to you the greatest items at a value that won't burn through every last cent. Estimating is our unparalleled purchasing power, store network the board and strategic organizations that permits us to offer these astonishing costs and most ideal worth. https://bulklinensupply.com/collections/restaurants